Episode 85: Shelly and Gage
The heavy click of the dorm room door did little to shut out the echoes of Ted’s parting words. Shelly collapsed onto her bed, the white lace of her shirt—the very shirt she had foolishly unbuttoned in the bright coastal sun—now feeling like a shroud of her own making.
How had a morning that started with so much hope devolved into such utter ruin?
She stared at the ceiling, her chest aching with the suffocating weight of a promise she was bound by honor to keep. Just hours ago on North Beach, Gage had handed her a secret that answered every confusing signal of the past two days. He wasn’t looking at her with desire; he was looking at her with the relief of a man who finally found a friend he could trust. His revelation—that he was gay, and that the truth had already cost him his last job in Washington—had instantly shattered Shelly’s brief, misplaced fantasy. He wasn't her future. He couldn't be.
But Ted didn't know that.
Ted had only seen the laughter, the shared donuts, and the scandalous lack of a bra beneath her translucent shirt—a desperate, clumsy attempt on her part to see if she could still make a man's head turn after months of feeling discarded. In his eyes, Gage was the new, muscular threat, a legend-killer taking his place. And because Shelly had given her word to protect Gage from the ruin of exposure, she had stood there frozen, letting Ted walk away into the misty afternoon believing a lie. She was losing the only man she truly loved to protect a secret that wasn't even hers to tell.
Deciding she couldn't bear to face anyone else, Shelly stood up to change. She peeled off the white lace shirt and threw it aside, leaving her shivering slightly in the cool room. Shelly caught a glimpse of herself in the small dresser mirror, her eyes dropping to her bare chest. A wave of self-consciousness hit her like a physical blow. Ted had always been so gentle, so reassuring about her body; he’d never cared how small her chest was, always making her feel beautiful just as she was. And yet, in a moment of sheer panic, she’d bared herself to a man who couldn't even see her that way.
The irony was a sharp, twisting knife.
She kicked off her jeans, slipping into her comfortable pajamas, before reaching into her drawer for an oversized shirt. Slipping it over her head, she felt a desperate need for comfort. She pulled out the photo album from her bag—the one filled with the glossy remnants of her and Ted's wild ride that summer.
She flipped the pages, her fingertips tracing the edges of the pictures. There they were, laughing, soaked in sea spray, radiant with a raw passion and a wild, carefree fun that felt a lifetime away now. The memories didn't soothe her; they broke her. The tears leaked out again, hot and fast, blurring the faces in the photos.
The door creaked open, and Maria stepped into the room. She took one look at Shelly's tear-streaked face and stopped dead in her tracks.
"Shelly? What on earth happened?" Maria asked, her voice dropping its usual mischievous edge, replacing it with genuine concern.
Shelly’s throat locked up. A desperate urge surged within her to just open the floodgates—to scream the truth, to tell Maria everything about Gage, about the beach, about the impossible corner she’d been backed into. But she choked it down. In a place where gossip spread faster than the incoming tide, she didn't know who could be trusted anymore. A secret like Gage's could ruin a life, and she had given her word.
She forced herself to take a ragged breath, closing the photo album with a soft thud.
"Maria, I wish I could tell you," Shelly whispered, her voice trembling as she looked up. "I really wish I could, but I can't. Ted is... he's so angry with me. We were supposed to have a perfect day together today. A fresh start. But I was off joking and walking on the beach with Gage, and I lost track of time. Ted's utterly convinced something is going on. I assured him, Maria. I swear I assured him that I wasn't interested in Gage romantically, but... he didn't believe me."
Maria sat beside her on the edge of the mattress, the springs groaning softly under their weight. "So, you're really not interested in Gage?" she asked, studying Shelly’s face. "I mean, I like short men personally, so I wouldn't be interested in him either. But you don't have *any* attraction to him?"
"No, I really, really don't," Shelly pleaded, her voice thick with unshed tears. She reached out and squeezed the stuffed teddy bear that Ted had bought her over the summer, clutching it against her oversized pajamas like a shield. She looked up at Maria, her eyes wide and desperate, grasping at absolutely any straw she could find to fix things without breaking her promise to Gage. "Do you think... do you think it would help if *you* told Ted that you don't think I'm interested in Gage?"
Maria grabbed Shelly’s hands gently, shaking her head. "No, darling. Even if I said it, Ted would just think I was doing damage control for you. And truthfully, I haven't been around you and Gage long enough to know anything about how you two interact. If I'd actually seen you together, maybe then I could say something to him, but I just don't know."
Hearing the hard truth of it, Shelly began to cry all over again, the heavy tears soaking into the fur of the teddy bear.
Maria watched her for a moment, sighing softly as she stood up to get ready for her evening walk. She stripped down without a care in the world, grabbing her deodorant and rolling it on before spraying her favorite body scent through the air. She scooped up her denim shorts, underwear, shirt, bra, and socks.
Shelly watched her, a familiar knot tightening in her stomach. She honestly didn't like how comfortable Maria was with just stripping down anywhere. Maria always justified it, of course, waving it off with her usual line: *"We're all girls here, Shelly. I don't like girls, you don't like girls, so I don't see the problem."*
Maria vanished into the washroom to brush her teeth and fix her hair, coming out a few minutes later completely dressed. "Well, I'm out of here," she said, giving a sympathetic look. "I really wish I could help, darling." With a final wave, she slipped out the door.
The moment the door clicked shut, a sudden, violent wave of panic washed over Shelly. Her breath caught in her throat. Maria’s casual talk about the girls' communal changing and showering had just triggered a terrifying realization.
Gage.
Gage was living in the men's dorms. And right now, he would be showering and changing in the exact same shared bathroom area right beside Ted.
Shelly went completely pale, the blood draining from her face. *I never thought about this,* she thought, her heart hammering against her ribs. *What if... what if Gage's type is Ted?*
The room seemed to spin. She felt utterly nauseated and deeply confused, her mind racing through the dark implications. She was doing the honorable thing by keeping Gage's secret, but by staying silent, was she inadvertently allowing a man who was attracted to men to shower completely naked right beside the man she loved?